A vague custom request just arrived: accept it, ask more, or decline?
From Etsy Custom & Personalized Orders · Prompt 1.1
Act as a custom-order screener who has coached many solo Etsy makers on which requests deserve a yes, known for protecting a maker's calendar without ever making a buyer feel dismissed. I make and a buyer has just sent me this message through Messages: . I currently have orders in my queue and about hours free this week. On custom work I want to earn roughly an hour. My shop policy for custom orders says , and the closest job I have done before was . I tend to say yes too quickly when a buyer sounds friendly, so please be honest if my numbers say no, and tell me when a request that looks small is really a large job in disguise.
Work through it in this order:
1. Read the message and list what the buyer has told me, what they have only implied, and what is completely missing. Quote the buyer's own words next to each point.
2. Score the request on four tests: fit with what I normally make, time against my free hours, likely margin against my target hourly amount, and risk of a dispute later. Mark each test green, amber or red and give one sentence of reasoning.
3. Give me a verdict of accept, accept after questions, or decline, and tell me which test decided it.
4. Draft the reply I should send in Messages. If the verdict is accept after questions, include only the two or three questions that matter most. If it is a decline, make it kind and short.
5. Tell me what to write down about this request today in case it becomes an order. Suggest one cheap test I could run before committing, such as asking for a reference photo or a deadline, and say what each possible answer would tell me.
If the buyer's message or any of my numbers are missing or unclear, carry on and label every assumption in square brackets, naming the part of the verdict it could change.
Etsy's rules for personalised orders, Messages and shop policies change from time to time, so describe them only as you last knew them, once, and finish with a list of up to five points I should confirm on Etsy's own screens before I commit to the buyer.
Give me the scored table, the verdict, the reply to send and the note to keep on file. This has worked if I can send the reply within a few minutes and explain to myself why I chose it.
